You may have heard the news: T-Mobile announced a new mobile phone plan this week that involves no contract, and no phone subsidies.
What’s most interesting about this news, and what nobody is talking about, is that other carriers don’t have subsidies, either.
The Merriam-Webster online dictionary defines a “subsidy” as “a grant or gift of money.”
The word “subsidy” is usually associated with a government giving money to an industry or organization as a matter of policy.
The US government, for example, collects taxes from the public and then gives some of that money to specific industries in order to prop up and influence the direction of national energy supplies, infrastructure, food and so on.
In order for something to be considered a “subsidy,” money must be transferred from one entity to another as both Merriam and Webster say as a “grant” or a “gift.”
If you give me money, you’re giving me a subsidy. If you give me money for now, but I have to give it back plus interest, that’s a loan.
(Ironically, “telecommunications” is the third largest industry to get subsidies from the US government. That money comes from US taxpayers. That means if you pay taxes in the United States, you actually subsidize AT&T, Sprint and Verizon, not the other way around.)
Use of the word “subsidy” as it relates to an assumed discount when purchased with a carrier contract is a mis-use of that word, a euphemism, a misdirection, a lie.
So let’s be clear about your average mobile phone contract.
They claim their proposition is this: “If you sign a two-year contract for phone and data service with us, we’ll pay for most of the cost of your smartphone.”
But that’s just spin – conceptual packaging of costs designed to maximize what you’re willing to pay.
The truth is that they are not paying for most of the cost of your phone. Be assured that you are paying the full cost of that phone, and then some. The carriers are not going off and getting money from elsewhere and redirecting it to you. That would be a subsidy.
What they are in fact doing is selling you a phone and a plan at a price that fully covers the total cost of both the phone and the plan and also leaves a hefty pile of cash for them to keep as profit.
The contract is the legal requirement for you to pay for all that with monthly payments, plus penalty fees if you exceed the terms of the contract — for example, if you exceed your “minutes.”
Regarding the phone, they are giving you a loan. They’re paying for the price of the phone up front, and then the repayment of that loan is built into your monthly payment, which you are required by contract to pay.
And that’s the problem. The terms of the loan they give you is a rip-off.
When you buy into a “subsidized” phone with a two-year contract, some number of dollars you’re paying each month is payment on that loan. Let’s call it $20 per month, which is the amount T-Mobile charges per month for the repayment of their loans for iPhones after you pay $99 up front according to their new plan. (It’s also the amount in a similar model outlined last week in the blog Phone Scoop.)
Because an average carrier contract has you paying typically about $200 up front for a high-end smartphone, we can assume that hypothetical $20 includes some interest. (An unlocked iPhone costs $649 from Apple. A “subsidized” phone from a carrier where, in our very conservative model, you’re paying $20 per month in payments and interest on your loan works out to $680 — the price of the phone, plus a total of $30 interest on the loan.)
If you immediately upgrade to a new phone after two years and sign a new, two-year contract, then you get another loan and the process continues.
If, however, you’re among the majority that waits some time before getting a new phone, you continue to pay your monthly loan payments on the phone, even though it has been paid off.
It’s like paying off your house and all the interest on your home loan after 15-years, but being required by the bank to continue paying your regular mortgage payments every month until you buy another house and get another loan.
That’s why carriers love the whole “subsidy” shell game. It hides your loan payments in a murky payment plan that definitely covers the cost of your phone, interest on the loan they gave you, the costs associated with your actual service plus more money to profit the carrier.
There’s no “subsidy” anywhere in this plan. They use the word to confuse you into taking out a very bad loan.
The reason the scheme works and the reason consumers don’t scrutinize what they’re actually paying for is a flaw in human reasoning called “present bias.” Humans will gladly pay more for something later if it means spending less now.
Interestingly, T-Mobile is also happy to give you a loan to buy your phone. But there are three differences.
First, when you’ve paid off the loan with T-Mobile, you stop making payments.
Second, they don’t charge you interest on the loan.
And, third, they give you a discounted price for the phone — for example (by the time you pay off your loan, you will have paid less than $600 for an iPhone 5).
You can also buy the unlocked phone at a discount price if you don’t take out the T-Mobile loan. For example, they charge $549.99 for the iPhone 5 ($100 less than Apple charges) if you pay the whole cost up front.
Or, you can just use the phone you already own.
In essence, they’ve de-coupled your monthly payment for wireless service from the loan they give you for your phone — the cost of service is the same whether you get a loan from them to buy a discounted phone or whether you bring your existing phone onto their network.
Ultimately, it’s all a shell game no matter what. Who knows, for example, if T-Mobile takes some of your money they charge you for the wireless service and use it to help discount the phone or carry the phone loans?
What’s good about T-Mobile’s plan is that the phones, loans and wireless service costs are all separated from each other.
T-Mobile’s new policies help shatter the “subsidy” scam that used to be nearly universal.
And the piece de resistance from T-Mobile’s point of view is that their loan program exploits “present bias” even more than conventional plans do. The proposition for consumers is: “Pay $99 now and the rest later.”
More importantly, though, I would like to destroy the absurd notion that subsidies exist anywhere in the industry. There are no subsidies. Subsidies are a myth.
The truth is that what carriers call “subsidies” are really very bad, very high-interest loans buried inside a shell game designed to confuse the public into spending far more for phones and wireless service than they really should.
Huawei’s AI Update: Things Are Moving Faster Than We Think
FEATURE | By Rob Enderle,
December 04, 2020
Keeping Machine Learning Algorithms Honest in the ‘Ethics-First’ Era
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE | By Guest Author,
November 18, 2020
Key Trends in Chatbots and RPA
FEATURE | By Guest Author,
November 10, 2020
FEATURE | By Samuel Greengard,
November 05, 2020
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE | By Guest Author,
November 02, 2020
How Intel’s Work With Autonomous Cars Could Redefine General Purpose AI
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE | By Rob Enderle,
October 29, 2020
Dell Technologies World: Weaving Together Human And Machine Interaction For AI And Robotics
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE | By Rob Enderle,
October 23, 2020
The Super Moderator, or How IBM Project Debater Could Save Social Media
FEATURE | By Rob Enderle,
October 16, 2020
FEATURE | By Cynthia Harvey,
October 07, 2020
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE | By Guest Author,
October 05, 2020
CIOs Discuss the Promise of AI and Data Science
FEATURE | By Guest Author,
September 25, 2020
Microsoft Is Building An AI Product That Could Predict The Future
FEATURE | By Rob Enderle,
September 25, 2020
Top 10 Machine Learning Companies 2020
FEATURE | By Cynthia Harvey,
September 22, 2020
NVIDIA and ARM: Massively Changing The AI Landscape
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE | By Rob Enderle,
September 18, 2020
Continuous Intelligence: Expert Discussion [Video and Podcast]
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE | By James Maguire,
September 14, 2020
Artificial Intelligence: Governance and Ethics [Video]
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE | By James Maguire,
September 13, 2020
IBM Watson At The US Open: Showcasing The Power Of A Mature Enterprise-Class AI
FEATURE | By Rob Enderle,
September 11, 2020
Artificial Intelligence: Perception vs. Reality
FEATURE | By James Maguire,
September 09, 2020
Anticipating The Coming Wave Of AI Enhanced PCs
FEATURE | By Rob Enderle,
September 05, 2020
The Critical Nature Of IBM’s NLP (Natural Language Processing) Effort
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE | By Rob Enderle,
August 14, 2020
Datamation is the leading industry resource for B2B data professionals and technology buyers. Datamation's focus is on providing insight into the latest trends and innovation in AI, data security, big data, and more, along with in-depth product recommendations and comparisons. More than 1.7M users gain insight and guidance from Datamation every year.
Advertise with TechnologyAdvice on Datamation and our other data and technology-focused platforms.
Advertise with Us
Property of TechnologyAdvice.
© 2025 TechnologyAdvice. All Rights Reserved
Advertiser Disclosure: Some of the products that appear on this
site are from companies from which TechnologyAdvice receives
compensation. This compensation may impact how and where products
appear on this site including, for example, the order in which
they appear. TechnologyAdvice does not include all companies
or all types of products available in the marketplace.